Pressure Cooker vs Slow Cooker: The Pros and Cons

Few meals stick to the ribs and provide almost instant comfort the way that slow-cooked one-pot meals do when the weather starts to get chilly.

Differences between slow cookers and pressure cookers. A slow cooker is a gentle process that uses low heat and low temperature, longer cooking times to help keep your dish from being overcooked or dried out. A pressure cooker can bring the same results in less than half the time by using high temperatures, and hot steam with high pressure.

The main difference home cooks face is in the amount of time these kitchen tools food cooks in vs how much time they want to spend in the kitchen.

The only problem with a slow cooker, though, is that it takes a long time to turn often tough and otherwise inedible ingredients into the kind of food you’d find in a four-star restaurant.

You have to get up early, you have to prep your meal in advance, and then you have to hope that nothing goes sideways during the day to cause your slow cooker cooking time to “go on the fritz”.

Of course, you could speed things up with pressure cooking – but that introduces a couple of curveballs into the mix, too.

People have been arguing both sides of the great pressure cooker vs slow cooker debate for decades now, and the odds are pretty good they’re going to keep right on arguing this debate for at least another generation (or two).

slow cooker stovetop pressure electric pressure cooker

This detailed breakdown of the pros and cons of both of these miracle kitchen appliances is my small contribution to the fight.

Hopefully, by the time I wrap up we shine a light on what these appliances do well, where they fall short, and maybe nudge you in the right direction towards what we think is the better choice. Let’s get right into it…

Pressure Cookers

Pressure cookers, up until just recently, were almost exclusively thought of as equipment used for canning and storing food for the long haul or to cook things like rice quickly and evenly.

Stovetop pressure cookers used to be a real nightmare to try and control, super difficult to dial in, and generally pretty unsafe.

It wasn’t at all uncommon for these kinds of appliances to “blow their top” without any warning at all – not only tossing superheated steam all over the place in the process but usually expelling whatever was inside the pressure cooker all over your kitchen, too!

Today’s pressure cookers, though, are a whole lot more advanced than they ever used to be.

In fact, many of the best pressure cooker options on the market today don’t ever see the top of a stove instead, they are 100% electric.

These electric models have automatic shut-offs built right in, and some even have advanced computer capabilities on board (including wireless internet) to make them about as safe and as easy to use as humanly possible. Not only that, but many of today’s best pressure cooker options are so much more than just a pressure cooker.

Most of them are now being called a “multi cooker” – the pressure cooker that handles double duty (and then some) as a pressure cooker, yogurt maker, a rice cooker, Sous vide, a tool for canning, a quick way to make two, and chili, a great way to make rice, and that’s just the tip of the iceberg. Slow cooker recipes like a pot roast are at home in today’s electric version of pressure cookers.

Related read What is a Multi-Cooker?

The safety features, the new locking mechanisms, and the automatic relief valves are a handful of things that today’s modern pressure cooker has going for them, too.

That’s not to suggest that today’s pressure cookers are perfect, though.

This type of cooker can be a nightmare to clean, you still have to babysit them (at least a little bit) to make sure that things don’t go sideways, and the high rate of speed during the pressurized cook usually cuts out a little bit of the deeper and more nuanced flavors you get from a slow cooker.

Pressure Cooker – Pros and Cons

Here’s a quick rundown of the pros and cons of today’s pressure cooker to give you a better idea of what they are bringing to the table:

Pressure Cooker – PROS

You can often cook a “slow cooker only” meal that might have taken eight hours or longer in about 90 minutes flat using higher temperatures
You don’t have to worry about a pressure cooker heating up your entire kitchen the way that a slow cooker might
By cooking with steam you’re able to retain a lot of the vitamins and minerals with a pressure cooker that would have been lost with other cooking methods
Most of today’s modern pressure cookers are “multi-cooker” units, that include a slow cook function, and do so much more than just speed up the cooking process
Many of today’s best pressure cookers even include Wi-Fi capabilities so that you can control your cooker from anywhere – including the office or at school – while online
Electric pressure cookers are even more integrated offering air fryer capabilities
Combine the temperature setting capabilities the fast cooking time, airtight seal from the locking lid you are going to save a lot of time

Pressure Cooker – Cons

On the flipside, pressure cookers are always a nightmare to clean. You have to pull everything apart, clean everything carefully, and then put everything back together – every single time you cook with one
You might not need to carefully watch every second of today’s modern pressure cooker, but they still have some risks with them and shouldn’t be left completely unattended
You need to be real careful when popping the top on modern pressure cookers, as the steam pressure can scald and burn you
You do lose a little bit of those nuanced and subtle flavors when you cook this quickly under pressure
The price tag on quality pressure cookers (especially those with multi cook functions) is almost always a lot higher than a slow cooker
You have to convert slow cooker cook times to account for the much more rapid cook time of a pressure cooker, and you often have to do that all on your own

Slow Cookers

The very first slow cooker (the actual slow cooker that would later become the legendary “Crock Pot”) was invented all the way back in 1940.

To put it bluntly, slow cookers have been around for a while – a long while!

And while some would say that this makes the slow cooker a little outdated and not quite as useful in today’s lighting fast-paced world, others would say that all this time has only made the slow cooker better. (Kind of how the slow cooker itself works.)

Related Read What are slow cookers?

Over decades the slow cooker technology has been refined, improved upon, and – quite literally – perfected.

In today’s slow cooking technology, the heat source is basically an encased heating element, which is very similar to the slow cooker of the past. But a lot more efficient, a lot more effective, and (believe it or not) a little bit faster!

Not too fast, though, as the slow and deliberate cooking process that these appliances use – perfecting low and slow – are responsible for transforming otherwise rather “blah” ingredients into something really spectacular.

Sure, you need to devote a decent chunk of time to preplanning how you’re going to use your slow cooker if you want to use it effectively.

And sure, you’re probably going to need to throw dinner together into this countertop appliance before you leave for school or work if you want to have it ready when you get home.

But these bulky, often cheap little units are truth tanks in the kitchen. They are legitimately set it and forget it solutions that make cooking downright effortless.

If you can rough chop ingredients (and sometimes you don’t even have to go that far), dump everything into your slow cooker, and then flip the switch to LOW – and then leave everything for hours and hours – you’re going to be able to make some amazing dishes with this simple set up.

Related read How slow cookers work!

Slow Cooker Pros and Cons

Let’s break down the pros and cons of today’s best slow cooker, shall we?

Slow Cooker – Pros

Aside from (very little) prep work you don’t have to do much of anything to make amazing meals – delicious meals – with this pressure cooker
Slow cooked food is capable of developing deeper, richer, more nuanced flavors than any other cooking method
You can totally transform the “cheap stuff” at the grocery store – including really inexpensive proteins (tough meat) – into a hot meal, one of the best tasting you’ve ever had, just with a little time and a slow cooker
Even the best slow cooker today is never going to threaten to break your bank account into tiny little pieces (they are always affordable)
Slow cookers come in a variety of sizes from a small 1-quart mini slow cooker all the way up to over 15-quarts for large families or entertaining
Shapes include the standard round model to square and of course oval that will fit a whole chicken and large cuts of meat
A glass lid that is vented to release any excess steam even though lower temperatures are used for cooking
You don’t have to worry about using a lot of electricity when you are running a slow cooker on LOW (or even on HIGH, for that matter)

Slow Cooker – Cons

Cook times are L-O-N-G, oftentimes approaching eight hours or longer. You’re not going to be able to throw together a slow cooker meal in a pinch, that’s for sure.
Slow cookers require you to be really organized if you’re going to use them effectively
Slow cookers are always a little bit bigger and a little bit bulkier than most of your other cookware and small appliance options, which can be a pain to keep on the counter or to find storage space for
Browning food with a slow cooker is next to impossible (inside the slow cooker, anyway)
There usually aren’t any other options to do anything other than slow cook on LOW, MEDIUM, or HIGH

Related read What are slow cookers?

Pressure Cooker vs Slow Cooker Comparision Chart

	Pressure Cooker	Slow Cooker
How they cook	Steam pressure	Low heat simmering
Cooking time	Quickly – 8-hour slow cooker meal can take 90 minutes in a pressure cooker	4 up to 8 hours or more
Appliance Versatility	Stovetop pressure cookers, only pressure cook and sterilize. Electric pressure cookers many have multi-function capabilities	Slow cookers only slow cook on low or high. A programmable slow cooker is now available
Modern capabilities	Electric pressure cookers can use Wifi technology for convenience	Slow cookers automatically know when to turn off, but some multi-slow cooker units will have Wifi compatibility
Size	Various sizes from 2-qt to 10-qt	Various sizes from 1-qt to 10-qt
Meal Preparation	Shop, chop, and pressure cook	Need to have all ingredients ready to allow for slow cooking time
Performance	Pressure cooking retains vitamins and minerals	Steam can escape through the valve in the lid of a slow cooker and with it some of the nutrients in your food
Economical	Pressure cooking while still producing tender meat the texture is quite different. (Cheap to run)	Use cheap cuts of meat and turn them into mouth-watering delights. (Cheap to run)
Safety	A stovetop and electric pressure cookers are safer than ever, always use the manufacturer’s specifications	Slow cookers are safe when following manufacturers’ specifications
Cleaning	Messier than a slow cooker, so a little harder to clean	Easy scrub cooking insert and whip downcasting
Storage	Can be clunky depending on the size	Can be clunky depending on the size
Price	More expensive	Affordable

FAQs

Quick answers to commonly asked questions about these different appliances the pressure cooker and slow cooker.

Can pressure cooker replace slow cooker?

The answer is yes! Pressure cookers can actually be quicker than slow cookers since they cook food at a higher temperature. And, like slow cookers, they can be used to make a variety of dishes from main courses to desserts. So if you’re short on time, a pressure cooker is definitely the way to go.

Is a slow cooker and pressure cooker the same?

A slow cooker cooks using moist heat to cook food slowly over a period of several hours. This gentle cooking method is ideal for tough cuts of meat, which become tender and flavorful after spending a few hours in the slow cooker. In contrast, a pressure cooker cooks food using high pressure to cook food quickly.

This makes it perfect for quick-cooking recipes like soups and stews that you want to get on the table fast. Pressure cookers can also be used to cook tough cuts of meat, but they will come out significantly different than if they were cooked in a slow cooker.

Do pressure cookers make meat more tender than a slow cooker?

In general, slow cookers and pressure cookers meat cook to be equally as tender. The main difference between the cooked meat is that slow-cooked meat is richer and full of flavor. Pressure cookers cannot reduce the liquid into a rich sauce as effectively as slow cookers.

Pressure Cooker vs Slow Cooker – Final Verdict

At the end of the day, you really can’t go wrong with either of these two amazing kitchen appliances.

You have learned that we no longer need the conventional cooking methods of a Dutch oven. Using these pots we were cooking over high heat for a long period of time to get our tough cuts of meat in our favorite hearty stew soft enough to chew.

A pressure cooker for home use is designed to get the job done in a hurry, but if you’re not in a rush or if you can set things up in the morning to eat at night a slow cooker develops even tastier flavors.

Of course, a pressure cooker (especially today’s pressure cooker) is generally a lot safer to use than a slow cooker – and almost always has a lot more functionality built right in.

When you get right down to it, the best small appliance to buy is a pressure cooker that doubles as a “multi-cooker”. Then you get the best of all worlds, having the opportunity to cook in slow cooker mode, pressure cooker mode, and a handful of other ways, too.

One-Pot Cooking Rocks

Related Read

How to Convert Slow Cooker Times

Pressure Cooker Temperature Chart (Time Conversions)

Pressure Cooker Size and Capacity (Charts and Guidelines)